The Old Dark House (1932)


Staying the night at the strange house of Femm for the Pre-Code blogathon.

Where to begin describing this sinister, fun, creepy and twisted James Whale Pre-Code treasure with a rich cast? Let’s start with the predicament of the leads: Melvyn Douglas, Raymond Massey and Gloria Stuart are in a car, caught in a terrible storm that triggers massive landslides and flooding, almost washing away and then burying them all in mud. They brave the danger with some choice sarcasm and wry observations, then happen to spy a mansion in which to seek refuge. The door they knock on is opened by Boris Karloff as a grim, hirsute, heavy-lidded, mumbling figure with a battered face. Melvyn Douglas comments: “Even Welsh ought not sound like that!” Karloff leads them inside the home where they meet the owners, the curiously named Femms, brother and sister played by Ernest Thesiger and Eva Moore. After some argument over whether or not they will be allowed to stay the night– “no beds! They can’t have beds!” screams Moore repeatedly– another couple arrive, also seeking shelter from the storm, namely Charles Laughton and his chorus girl companion Lilian Bond. Little do these guests know, they’ll all soon be seeking shelter from the spectrum of weirdos in the Femm house.


The Old Dark House is not full-on horror; it gets increasingly dangerous and spooky toward the end, but is a picture dominated by brilliant weirdness and warped comedy. I love the deadpan delivery, the rich sarcasm, the clever passive-aggressive putdowns and easy to miss gestures, some of which rival the most sophisticated and sparkly romantic comedies of the era. For example, as Thesiger welcomes the first trio of guests, he grabs a pitcher of flowers and dryly states, “my sister was just about to arrange these” before pitching the bouquet into the fireplace. It’s an efficient gesture, absurd on its own, one of many darkly funny touches by Whale, and it also speaks volumes about Thesiger’s feelings for his sister, as well as his sense of futility about doing anything beautiful or productive in this cursed house. Thesiger, whom Whale fans will know well as Dr. Pretorius in The Bride of Frankenstein, is fabulous as the gaunt, prim, easily rattled yet somehow intimidating host.


During dinner his reply, rebuttal and punctuation to any statement is to offer a side dish. “Have a potato,” he repeats, in a way that sounds like an order and effectively cuts off all conversation. The sight of Massey scraping something black off those potatoes is a fun part of the camera’s pan across the dinner table to show us the uncomfortable meal; it ends at Eva Moore’s side so we can watch her stuffing forkfuls into her face at a dizzying pace. Thesiger turns white as a sheet at the prospect of having the roads blocked by the storm; that puzzles Massey, Stuart and Douglas but not the viewer, who is correct to sense there’s something in that house far scarier than the questionable food and the two Femms we’ve met so far.


As the storm rages on, Stuart goes to change out of her wet clothes into a revealing and clingy white dress, which Whale wanted so that Stuart would seem like a glowing flame running through the dark house. Stuart is watched, pawed and harshly judged by Eva Moore, who tells the story of a dead Femm sister, scorns Stuart’s taste in showy, silky garb, tells her how those wardrobe choices lead to sin, depravity and doom, and how her fine, pale skin will soon “rot.” The speech Moore launches into was used verbatim by Dom Deluise in Haunted Honeymoon (1986) which says more than I ever could about the campy value of the monologue. The fascinating thing about Moore’s speech is that, as she’s delivering it, Whale cuts and assembles the footage in mid-sentences from various angles so that it seems unreal and ready-made for the next sequence where the same words ring in Stuart’s memory and send her screaming from the room. Poor Stuart is later pawed by Karloff who flips over the dinner table and chases her around the house until Massey brains him with a lamp.


Massey and Thesiger go up the stairs for a replacement lamp but Thesiger freezes, giving the excuse that the lamp is heavy, gosh this a lot of stairs to climb, they should just say they went, and anyway he shouldn’t go places he doesn’t want to go; the non sequitur strongly hints to Massey that they are no longer speaking of lamps. Sure enough, Massey discovers a third Femm, Sir Roderick the centenarian patriarch, locked in an upper floor bedroom. Sir Roderick is played by a woman, Elspeth Dudgeon, in drag and beard, with makeup by master monster maker Jack Pierce and credited as Jack Dudgeon, but there’s no attempt to disguise her frail female voice and hands. Whale never told anyone he cast a woman until the shoot was over, which must have brought the right amount of real strangeness to the scene. Dudgeon tells Massey and Stuart about a fourth Femm living on an even higher floor (the higher you go the more insane presumably). That one is a pyromaniac played by Brember Wills who keeps being let loose by his close buddy Karloff; when you next spot a hand sliding down the bannister, you know Femm #4 is roaming about and the fireworks are about to begin.


Quirky, creative and off-kilter throughout, The Old Dark House is delightfully disturbing and many fans’ picks for the greatest movie James Whale made. It was also Charles Laughton’s first Hollywood film, and he’s great as the brash and bitter braggart and overachiever with a heart, who generously sprinkles nervous laughter into every sentence. He tells the story of losing his wife to her insecurity around the upper class, and of his wanting success as the best revenge. His lady friend Bond is a down to earth showgirl who dances around in Douglas’ shoes (earning a dirty look from Moore) and then tells Melvyn Douglas that Laughton never touches her, expecting her to act only as attractive arm candy to maintain his showy facade. Douglas is another valuable player in this looney bin, bringing to some great moments and comebacks his signature easy and mocking spin, and he gets to romance and play dashing hero to Bond. With perfect timing, Douglas plays along with Thesiger’s dramatics in offering food and drink; Thesiger: “I’ll give you a toast that you will not appreciate, being young. I give you — illusion!” / Douglas: “Illusion, huh? I’m precisely the right age for that toast, Mister.” Douglas will need that gin for the final graphically violent struggle he has with firestarter Femm.


There’s comedy in Eva Moore’s partial deafness that works more like delayed hearing, as she answers queries made three sentences ago. There’s comedy in Laughton’s snoring through a romantic scene and marriage proposal, and comedy in most of the inane yet gripping and revealing conversation, the reaction shots, and side-eyeing that makes up the bulk of the film. The sad part came when the movie, though fairly successful at the box office, was rumoured lost by the late 1950’s, remade weakly (to put it kindly) by William Castle in 1963, and went unseen until restoration in 1970. It may have struck some as an incongruous piece for Whale to drop between things like Frankenstein and The Invisible Man but I’m one of many who finds it his essential work, and terrific, sinister fun. Come for one of Karloff’s best performances, stay for the ensemble insanity until the rooster crows in the “cold light of day.”

Have a potato?

This post is part of the Pre-Code Blogathon hosted by Danny at and Karen at Shadows & Satin.

gif source


21 thoughts on “The Old Dark House (1932)”

  1. A splendid essay . . . and, for me, a timely reminder that I’m overdue to watch this. That’s the trouble with these blogathons — they tend to stack up the to-be-watched pile!

    1. No kidding, that to watch list is forever growing. I honestly have trouble making it through all the wonderful posts people do. Thanks very much for the compliment!

  2. I tend not to be a big fan of horror, but you’ve done a great job in writing this up. I agree with John above, the list grows ever longer!

    1. This is a good movie for you if you’re not into horror, it’s not scary, more a weird comedy with some creeps thrown in, and if you like anyone in that cast you have to check it out. Thanks for reading!

  3. Loved your post, Kristina. You know I’m no scary movie lover, but this one really sounds like one I’d like to check out! Thanks for introducing me to (yet another) movie I’ve never heard of, and for contributing this most awesome post to our blogathon!

    1. Yes this is a good one for those who don’t like too many scares, there’s more wit and strangeness. Plus glamour, and potatoes. Thanks to you and Danny for hosting this great event!

  4. TODH is one of my favorites! Thesinger, Laughton, and Karloff are wonderful, but the highlight for me is Eva Moore as Rebecca. She’s a hoot!

    1. She was fabulous! So persistent in her fanaticism, loved the hard of hearing bit and her judging looks of the younger ladies. Great movie. Thanks for reading.

  5. Took me forever to eventually see this thanks to Gen X store. 🙂 Just think someday Massey would be accused of looking just like Boris Karloff in Arsenic and Old Lace.

    1. That’s right I was reminded of that in my reading for this post. Massey had no love for this one but I thought he was great! Him Laughton and Douglas make it so much more than a spooky house movie.

  6. You capture the feel of the film very well here – it isn’t really horror at all, just darkly bizarre. The setting, cast and Whale’s inventive direction make it a compelling watch, and there’s always so much going on that it never gets stale either.

    1. Right, as a horror fan I don’t find this scary at all, and it has some great comedy. Whale was really an amazing talent, with a clever, dark sense of humour. Thanks!

    1. I hope you get the chance to check it out, it is fun if you like dark humour. And how can you not like these stars? Thanks for reading!

    1. Fun cast who do wonders with the weirdness too! Karloff might be th draw for many but Laughton and Melvyn Douglas, et al. are so great. Check it out and see what you think.

  7. Finally saw this recently, and it’s a terrific film for all of the reasons you mentioned. It’s got the right combination of horror and (intentional) humor, and while Karloff always seemed to be playing creepy in these early pre-Code films, it’s amazing how many variations he put on that type of role. Nice write-up.

    1. Thanks very much, and well put re Karloff, he didn’t really do much in this one but makes such an impact. There was a bit in the credits telling the audience this was indeed the same actor from Frankenstein and how that’s a testament to his talent.

      I love the combo of horror and comedy and this one balances those so well.

  8. Just had to pop over to say that I heard about this movie on a podcast today, remembered that you’d written about it, and just had to read your post again. Now I REALLY want to see it! LOL

    1. Excellent! This is kind of creaky but that fits the Old House theme just fine. I always marvel at how these guests just kind of shrug at all the weirdos and go, ok, I guess we’ll stay here. I’d rather sleep in the car!

Comments are closed.